Artha Vijnana: Journal of The Gokhale Institute of Politics and Economics

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access
Open Access Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Restricted Access Subscription Access

Adam Smith vis-a-vis Neoclassical Economics:A Retrospective Glance


Affiliations
1 Ananda Mohan College, Raja Ram Mohan Sarani, College Street, Kolkata 700009, West Bengal, India
     

   Subscribe/Renew Journal


Many stalwarts have characterized Adam Smith as the “pioneer” of neoclassical economics as he prefigured the formal-analytical structure of theorizing in it. What follows examines their claim that he is a pioneer of its analytical structure. It upholds the view that the claim is unjustifiable because of the importance of some notions in Smith’s analysis that are decreed nonsensical by the said economists, as also of some broader theoretical issues.

The scientific philosophy of logical positivism, its impact on the methodology of neoclassical economics, and the difference between the latter and Smith’s thought are accordingly discussed below.


Subscription Login to verify subscription
User
Notifications
Font Size

  • Arrow, Kenneth J. and F.H. Hahn (1971), General Competitive Analysis, San Francisco, HoldenDay Inc.

  • Aspromourgos, T. (2009), The Science of Wealth: Adam Smith and the Framing of Political Economy, Routledge.

  • Ayer, A.J. (1966), Editor’s Introduction, in Logical Positivism, (Ed.) A.J. Ayer, Free Press.

  • ---------- (2001) [1936], Language Truth and Logic, Penguin Books.

  • Black, R.D. Collison (1995) [1976], Smith’s Contribution in Historical Perspective, In Economic Theory and Policy in Context: The Selected Essays of R.D. Collison Black, Economists of the Twentieth Century Series, (Eds.) Mark Perlman and Mark Blaug Aldershot, U.K.: Edward Elgar.

  • Blaug, M. (1992) [1980], The Methodology of Economics or How Economists Explain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

  • ---------- (1997) [1962], Economic Theory in Retrospect, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Boettke, Peter J. (2010), Twentieth Century Economic Methodology, in 21st Century Economics: A Reference Handbook, Vol. 1, (Ed.) Rhona C. Free, Sage Publications Inc., May, pp. 33-43.

  • Carey, I.V. (1998), The Invisible Hand of Natural Selection, and Vice Versa, Biology and Philosophy, 13(3): 427-442.

  • Cherry, T.L., P. Frykblom and J.F. Shogren (2002), Hardnose the Dictator, American Economic Review, 92(4): 1218-1221, September.

  • Coase, R.H. (1976), Adam Smith’s View of Man, The Journal of Law and Economics, 19(3): 529-546, October.

  • Cosmides, L. and J. Tooby (1994), Better than Rational: Evolutionary Psychology and the Invisible Hand, American Economic Review, 84(May): 327-332.

  • Darwin, C. (1871), The Descent of Man, New York: D. Appleton and Company, Available at: http://books.google.com.

  • Dobb, Maurice (1973) [1975], Theories of Value and Distribution since Adam Smith, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Evensky, J. (2005), Adam Smith’s Moral Philosophy: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective on Markets, Law, Ethics, and Culture, Cambridge University Press.

  • Fisher, I. (1991) [1892 ], Mathematical Investigations in the Theory of Value and Prices, Reprint, Augustus M. Kelley, Fairfield, N.J.

  • Friedman, Milton (1970) [1953], Essays in Positive Economics, Part I - The Methodology of Positive Economics University of Chicago Press.

  • Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1976), Energy and Economic Myths, Pergemon.

  • ---------- (1979), Methods in Economic Science, Journal of Economic Issues, XIII(2): 317-328, June.

  • ---------- (1981) [1971], Entropy Law and the Economic Processes, Harvard University Press.

  • Grampp, William D. (1948), Adam Smith and Economic Man, Journal of Political Economy, 56(4): 315-336.

  • Griswold, C. (1999), Adam Smith and the Virtue of Enlightenment, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

  • Haakenssen, Knud (1981), The Science of a Legislator: The Natural Jurisprudence of David Hume and Adam Smith, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

  • Hempel, Carl G. (1959), The Empiricist Criteria of Meaning, in Logical Positivism (Ed.), A.J. Ayer (Glencoc, III: The Free Press).

  • Hempel, Carl G. and Paul Oppenheim (1948), Studies in the Logic of Explanation, Philosophy of Science, 15(2): 135-175.

  • Hollander, Samuel (1973), The Economics of Adam Smith, London, Heinnemann Educational Books.

  • ---------- (1977): Adam Smith and Self-interest Axiom, Journal of Law and Economics, 20(1): 133-152.

  • Huchison, Terence W. (1938), The Significance and Basic Postulates of Economic Theory, Macmillan.

  • Jevons, W.S. (1905), Future of Political Economy, in The Principles of Economics: A Fragment of Treatise on the Industrial Mechanism of Society and Other Papers, Macmillan, London.

  • ---------- (1965) [1871], The Theory of Political Economy, New York Augustus M. Kelly.

  • Khalil, E.L. (2009), Self-deceit and Self-serving Bias: Adam Smith on 'General Rules, Journal of Institutional Economics, 5(2): 251-258.

  • Kim, K. (1994), Adam Smith: A Relationship between Metaphysics and Science, Ph.D. Thesis University of Glasgow.

  • Knight, Frank H. (1947), Freedom and Reform, New York, Harper & Bros, cited in Grampp, W.D (1948).

  • Marshall, A. (2010) [1890], Principles of Economics, Macmillan, 758-759, Online Library of Liberty fund, http://oll.libertyfund.org.

  • Mascollel, Whinston and Green (1995), Micro-economic Theory, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • Meek, R.L. (1971), Smith, Turgot, and the ‘Four Stages’ Theory, History of Political Economy, 3(1): 9-27.

  • ---------- (1976), Social Science and the Ignoble Savage, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

  • Mill, J.S. (1967), Collected Works, Essays on Economy and Society, Vol. 4 (Ed.), J.M. Robson Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  • Mises, L. (2007) [1945], Human Action: A Treatise on Economics, Indianapolis, IN. Liberty fund.

  • Montes, L. (2003), Smith and Newton: Some Methodological Issues Concerning General Equilibrium Theory, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 2(5): 723-747.

  • ---------- (2004), Adam Smith in Context: A Critical Reassessment of Some Central Components of His Thought, Palgrave-Macmillan.

  • ---------- (2006), Adam Smith Real Newtonian, in A History of Scottish Economic Thought (Eds.), Alexander Dow and Sheila Dow, Routledge.

  • ---------- (2006), On Adam Smith’s Newtonianism and General Economic Equilibrium Theory, in New Voices on Adam Smith (Eds.), Leonidas Montes and Eric Schliesser, Routledge.

  • Muller, Jerry (1993), Adam Smith in His Time and Ours: Designing the Decent Society, New York, The Free Press.

  • Newton, I. (1931) [1704], Opticks: or, a Treatise of the Reflections, Refractions, Inflections and Colours of Light, London: William Innys.

  • Poinsot, L. (1803), Eléments de Statique (translated as The Elements of Statics in 1848 by Thomas Sutton).

  • Popper, Karl (1963), Conjectures and Refutations, London: Routledge and Keagan Paul.

  • Raphael, D.D. (1997), ‘Smith’ in Three Great Economists, Keith Thomas (Ed.), Oxford, Oxford University Press.

  • Robbins, L. (1932), An Essay on the Nature And Significance of Economic Science, Macmillan, London.

  • Rothschild, E. (1994), Adam Smith and the Invisible Hand, The American Economic Review, 84(2): 319-322, Papers and Proceedings of the Hundred and Sixth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association, May.

  • Samuelson, P.A. (1977), A Modern Theorist’s Vindication of Adam Smith, American Economic Review, 67(I): 42-49, February.

  • Samuelson, P.A. and William D. Nordhaus (1989), Economics, 13thEdition, N.Y. et. al.: McGrawHill.

  • Schumpeter, J.A. (1953), History of Economic Analysis, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

  • Screpanti, E. and S. Zamagni (1995), An Outline of the History of Economic Thought, Clarendon Press Oxford.

  • Sen, A.K. (1987), On Ethics and Economics, Oxford University Press.

  • Skinner, A.D. (1972), Adam Smith: Philosophy and Science, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 19(3): 307-319.

  • Smith, Adam (1976 ), Correspondence of Adam Smith, edited By E.C. Mossner and I.S. Ross, The Glasgow edition of the Works and Correspondence of Adam Smith, Liberty Fund, p. 288.

  • ---------- (1982) [1795], Essays on Philosophical Subjects (Eds.), W.P.D Wightman and J.C Bryce with Dugald Stewart’s Account of Adam Smith (Ed), Ross I.S, Glasgow Edition Liberty Classics Indianapolis.

  • ---------- (1984) [1759], The Theory of Moral Sentiments, D.D. Raphael and A.L. Macfie (Eds.), Glasgow Edition Liberty Classics Indianapolis.

  • ---------- (1981) [1776], An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, R.H.

  • Campbell and A.S. Skinner (Eds.), Glasgow Edition Liberty Classics Indianapolis.

  • Sowell, T. (1979), Adam Smith in Theory and Practice, in Adam Smith and Modern Political Economy: Bicentennial Essays on Wealth of Nations.

  • Stewart, Dugald (1982) [1793], Account of the Life and Writings of Adam Smith, LL.D (Ed.), I.S. Ross in Adam Smith: Essays on Philosophical Subjects, W.P.D. Wightman and J.C. Bryce (Eds.), Glasgow Edition Liberty Classics Indianapolis, pp. 270-351.

  • Stigler, G. (1981), Economics or Ethics?, In Tanner Lectures on Human Values, Vol. II (Ed.), S.

  • McMurrin, Cambridge University Press.

  • Stigler, George (1976), The Success and Failures of Professor Smith, Journal of Political Economy, 84(6): 1199-1213.

  • Teichgraeber, Richard FIII (1986), Free Trade and Moral Philosophy: Rethinking the Sources of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations, Durham, Duke University Press.

  • Werhame, Patricia H. (1991), Adam Smith and His Legacy for Modern Capitalism, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

  • Wight, J.B. (2007), The Treatment of Smith’s Invisible Hand, Journal of Economic Education, Summer, 38(3): 341-358.

  • ---------- (2009), Adam Smith on Instincts, Affection, and Informal Learning: Proximate Mechanisms in Multilevel Selection, Review of Social Economy, 67(1): 95-113, Ethics and Economics, March.

  • ---------- (2015), Ethics in Economics, Stanford University Press, Stanford, California.

  • Winch, D. (1978), Adam Smith’s Politics: An Essay in Historiographic Revision, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

  • Young, Jeffrey (1997), Economics as a Moral Science: The Political Economy of Adam Smith, Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, Cambridge.

  • Zak, Paul J. (2011), The Physiology of Moral Sentiments, Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 77(1): 53–65.

  • ---------- (2012), The Moral Molecule: The Source of Love and Prosperity, Dutton, New York.


Abstract Views: 490

PDF Views: 0




  • Adam Smith vis-a-vis Neoclassical Economics:A Retrospective Glance

Abstract Views: 490  |  PDF Views: 0

Authors

Nandini Daniari
Ananda Mohan College, Raja Ram Mohan Sarani, College Street, Kolkata 700009, West Bengal, India

Abstract


Many stalwarts have characterized Adam Smith as the “pioneer” of neoclassical economics as he prefigured the formal-analytical structure of theorizing in it. What follows examines their claim that he is a pioneer of its analytical structure. It upholds the view that the claim is unjustifiable because of the importance of some notions in Smith’s analysis that are decreed nonsensical by the said economists, as also of some broader theoretical issues.

The scientific philosophy of logical positivism, its impact on the methodology of neoclassical economics, and the difference between the latter and Smith’s thought are accordingly discussed below.


References





DOI: https://doi.org/10.21648/arthavij%2F2018%2Fv60%2Fi3%2F176170