Journal of Intellectual Property Rights

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Prior Art searches in Software Patents-Issues Faced


Affiliations
1 CSIR Unit for Research and Development of Information Products, Tapovan, S.No. 113 & 114, NCL Estate, Pashan Road, Pune - 411 008, Maharashtra, India
 

Prior-art-search is a critical activity carried out by intellectual property professionals. It is usually performed based on known source o f literature to ascertain novelty in a said invention. Prior-art-searches are also carried out for invalidating a patent, knowing state o f the art, freedom to operate studies etc. In many technological domains such as chemistry, mechanical etc., prior art search is easy as compared to domain such as software. In software domain, prior-art can prove to be a complex and tedious process relying heavily on non-patent literature which acts as a pointer to the current technological trends rather than patent documents. This paper tries to highlight the issues faced by patent professionals while performing prior-art search in the field o f software patents.

Keywords

Patents, Software Patents, World Intellectual Property Organisation, Prior Art, Search Issues.
User
Notifications
Font Size

  • Deshpande N, Ahmed S & and Khode A, Web based targeted advertising: A study based on patent information, Procedia Economics and Finance, 11 (July 2014) 522-535.

  • Ahmed S, Khode A, Arya R & Hirwani R R, Understanding Patent Mining using Analysis o f the Samsung Patent Portfolio as— A Case Study, In Proceedings o f International Conference on Bridging—The Gap between Management Strategies and Execution, Pune, December 2013, 45-48.

  • Deshpande N, Ahmed S & and Khode A, Business intelligence through patinformatics: A study o f energy efficient data centres using patent data, Journal o f Intelligence Studies in Business, 6 (3) (December 2016) 13-26.

  • Merges R P & Nelson R R, On the complex economics o f patent scope, Columbia Law Review, 90 (4) (May 1990) 839-916.

  • Bekkers R N A, Martinelli A & Tamagni F, The causal effect o f including standards-related documentation into patent prior art: Evidence from a recent EPO policy change”, In European Economic Association 31th annual congress o f the European Economic Association and the 69th European meeting o f the Econometric Society, Geneva, 2016, 22.

  • Gaff B M & Rubinger B, The significance o f prior art, Computer, 47 (8) (August 2014) 9-11.

  • Mahdabi P, Keikha M, Gerani S, Landoni M & Crestani F, Building queries for prior-art search, In Information Retrieval Facility Conference, Vienna, 2011, 3-15.

  • Rubinger B, Locating prior art gold: The five keys to successfully uncovering strong prior art, Intellectual Property Today, (July 2011) 2-4.

  • Magdy W, Lopez P & Jones G J, Simple v sophisticated approaches for patent prior-art search, In Advances in Information Retrieval, Dublin, 725-728.

  • Sampat B N, When do applicants search for prior art?, Journal o f Law and Economics, 53 (2) (May 2010) 399-416.

  • Azzopardi L, Vanderbauwhede W & Joho H, Search system requirements o f patent analysts, In Proceedings o f the 33rd International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval, Geneva, 2010, 775-776.

  • Ji Y & Guo F, Prior art status o f drug standard evidence in China's pharmaceutical patent invalidation process, Biotechnology Law Report, 35 (3) (2016) 93-97.

  • Lupu M, Mayer K, Tait J & Trippe A J, Current challenges in patent information retrieval, Heidelberg, Germany: Springer, 2011.

  • WIPO, (May 2018). WIPO IP Statistics Data Center [Online],. https://www3.wipo.int/ipstats/index.htm (accessed on 20 November 2018).

  • Bessen J, The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis (3 September 2013). https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/09/03/the-patent-troll-crisis-is-really-a-software-patent-crisis/ (accessed on 16 June 2017).

  • Shaikh S A & Londhe B R, Intricacies o f software protection: A techno - legal review, Journal o f Intellectual Property Rights, 21 (3) (2016) 157-165.

  • Intellogist. (NA). Computer and Information Sciences Searching Best Practices [Online], http://www.intellogist.com/wiki/Computer_and_Information_Sciences_Searching_Best_Practices (accessed on 16 January 2016).

  • Dulken S van, Do you know English? The challenge o f the English language for patent searchers, World Patent Information, 39 (October 2014) 35-40.

  • Baio, A Patent Lie: How Yahoo Weaponized My Work (13 March 2012) [Online], https://www.wired.com/2012/03/opinion-baio-yahoo-patent-lie/ (accessed on 18 June 2017).

  • Corella F, Patent Illustrates Five Different Problems with Software Patents (21 April 2014) [Online], https://pomcor.com/2014/04/21/patent-illustrates-five-different-problems-with-software-patents/ (accessed on 18 June 2017).


Abstract Views: 173

PDF Views: 127




  • Prior Art searches in Software Patents-Issues Faced

Abstract Views: 173  |  PDF Views: 127

Authors

Shabib Ahmed Shaikh
CSIR Unit for Research and Development of Information Products, Tapovan, S.No. 113 & 114, NCL Estate, Pashan Road, Pune - 411 008, Maharashtra, India
Alok Khode
CSIR Unit for Research and Development of Information Products, Tapovan, S.No. 113 & 114, NCL Estate, Pashan Road, Pune - 411 008, Maharashtra, India
Nishad Deshpande
CSIR Unit for Research and Development of Information Products, Tapovan, S.No. 113 & 114, NCL Estate, Pashan Road, Pune - 411 008, Maharashtra, India

Abstract


Prior-art-search is a critical activity carried out by intellectual property professionals. It is usually performed based on known source o f literature to ascertain novelty in a said invention. Prior-art-searches are also carried out for invalidating a patent, knowing state o f the art, freedom to operate studies etc. In many technological domains such as chemistry, mechanical etc., prior art search is easy as compared to domain such as software. In software domain, prior-art can prove to be a complex and tedious process relying heavily on non-patent literature which acts as a pointer to the current technological trends rather than patent documents. This paper tries to highlight the issues faced by patent professionals while performing prior-art search in the field o f software patents.

Keywords


Patents, Software Patents, World Intellectual Property Organisation, Prior Art, Search Issues.

References