Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access
Open Access Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Restricted Access Subscription Access

Animal and Human Experiments in Medical Curriculum: Students' Attitudes and Ethical Issues


Affiliations
1 Department of Physiology, S.S. Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre, Davangere 577 005, Karnataka, India
2 Department of Forensic Medicine, S.S. Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre, Davangere 577 005, Karnataka, India
3 Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, College of Dental Sciences, Davangere 577 004, Karnataka, India
     

   Subscribe/Renew Journal


This study reveals the attitudes of medical students towards animal and human experiments. About 100 medical students [44 males and 56 females] who have performed animal and human experiments were subjected to a questionnaire method. The questionnaire consisted of, in part, statements for which the students responded using a five point Likert type scale. Several open ended questions pointing towards ethical issues in experimentation were also given to students and they were asked to list advantages and disadvantages of animal and human experiments. About 87% of the students preferred human experiments [P<0.05]. This preference was related more to issue of more informative and easy to perform human experiments rather than enjoyability and overall understanding of the experiments. A good number of students identified difficulties and ethical issues related to animal experiments. Present study shows that, medical students prefer introduction of large number of human experiments, though they realize the importance and value of animal experiments.

Keywords

Attitudes, Medical Students, Animal Experiments
Subscription Login to verify subscription
User
Notifications
Font Size


  • Foreman J.Physicians support the use of animals in medical education. Archives of Opthalmology 1992; 110:324.

  • The breeding of and experiments on Animals (control and supervision rules).1998. The Gazette of India no.809.

  • Dhruv Mankad. In Medical Education Reexamined 1991.Bombay.mfc-CED (Medico Friend circle and centre for Education and Documentation).

  • Ghek SM. Animals for teaching purposes; Medical student’s attitude. Med Educ 1995; 29:39-42.

  • Pardes H, West A, Pincus HA .Physicians and animal rights movement. N Engl J Med1991; 324:1640-1643.

  • Willis LR, Besch HR. Effect of experience on medical students attitudes towards animal laboratories in Pharmacology education. Acad Med 1995; 70:67-69.

  • Sharma KN,Subhasini AV,Sinha KP,Bijalani RL,Kulkarni SK,Maini BK. Laboratory exercises:Prons and cons.In Bijlani RL,Nayar U,eds Teaching Physiology 1983-Trends and tools. New Delhi. All India Institute of Medical Sciences:51-56.

  • Council on Scientific Affairs.American Medical Education. Council report,use of animals in medical education.JAMA 1991;266:836-837.

  • Ammons SW.Use of live animals in the cirrucula of U.S Medical schools in 1994. Acad Med 1995; 70:740-743.

  • The development of three Rs concept.Altern Lab Anim 1995; 23(3):298-304.

  • Greenwald GS.ACDP survey of use of animals in teaching Physiology. Physiologist 1985;28:478-80.

  • Theime Interactive. Virtual Physiology. The truly interactive simulation Software Promotional Brochure.http:// www.Theime.com

  • Critical concepts Inc,CCI. Critical concepts releases simulations on CD-ROM: Academia can save thousands using computer simulation.Company press release 1999. http://www.Laketech.com

  • Intelitool:Physiogrip and Spirocomp. Capabilities and features. Promotional brochures 1998. http:// www.Intelitool.com

  • Festing FW. The Scope for improving the design of laboratory animal’s experiments. Lab animals 1992:26(4):256-268.

  • Bernard ND.Stolz, Baron L. Use of and alternatives in laboratory medical courses at U.S.Medical schools. J Med Edu 1988; 63:720-722.


Abstract Views: 308

PDF Views: 0




  • Animal and Human Experiments in Medical Curriculum: Students' Attitudes and Ethical Issues

Abstract Views: 308  |  PDF Views: 0

Authors

Chandrashekhar Karpoor
Department of Physiology, S.S. Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre, Davangere 577 005, Karnataka, India
Vijay Jatti
Department of Forensic Medicine, S.S. Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre, Davangere 577 005, Karnataka, India
Savitha S. Shettar
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, College of Dental Sciences, Davangere 577 004, Karnataka, India

Abstract


This study reveals the attitudes of medical students towards animal and human experiments. About 100 medical students [44 males and 56 females] who have performed animal and human experiments were subjected to a questionnaire method. The questionnaire consisted of, in part, statements for which the students responded using a five point Likert type scale. Several open ended questions pointing towards ethical issues in experimentation were also given to students and they were asked to list advantages and disadvantages of animal and human experiments. About 87% of the students preferred human experiments [P<0.05]. This preference was related more to issue of more informative and easy to perform human experiments rather than enjoyability and overall understanding of the experiments. A good number of students identified difficulties and ethical issues related to animal experiments. Present study shows that, medical students prefer introduction of large number of human experiments, though they realize the importance and value of animal experiments.

Keywords


Attitudes, Medical Students, Animal Experiments

References