Asian Journal of Nursing Education and Research

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access
Open Access Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Restricted Access Subscription Access

Performance of Nursing Students in Psychiatric Nursing using Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) Versus Traditional Practical Examination (TPE)- A Comparative Approach


Affiliations
1 Apollo College of Nursing, Chennai, India
2 Faculty of Nursing, Sri Ramachandra University, Chennai, India
     

   Subscribe/Renew Journal


Determination of the quality of evaluation is an ongoing challenge to all educators. Selection of appropriate evaluation methods can enhance learning ability among nursing students and their performance in clinical tasks. The OSCE is a method of clinical evaluation which is highly comprehensive, systematic and objective and provides a uniform basis for evaluation of students. The present study was carried out to compare the nursing students’ performance between Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) and Traditional Practical Examination (TPE) in psychiatric nursing at Apollo College of Nursing, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, South India. Approval of the study was obtained from the Institutional review board, and Principal of Apollo College Nursing. Permission was obtained from the concerned authorities of the Psychiatric Hospital. Setting was selected through purposive sampling technique. The research design used for the study was randomized cross over research design with two groups. The study was conducted among 84 (42 students in each group) III year B.Sc. Nursing students, were selected using the consecutive sampling technique. The study subjects were randomly allocated to two groups (Group I and Group II) and then sequentially received two phases of intervention of OSCE and TPE or vice versa. Seventeen stations (including one rest station) OSCE and TPE were conducted in the private psychiatric hospital (100 marks each) with one-month washout period between these Examinations. Tools used in the study include baseline characteristics of the students, OSCE and TPE evaluation formats which were developed by the researcher. The collected data were organized, tabulated and statistically analyzed using appropriate descriptive and inferential statistics by SPSS software statistical computer package version 16. Study findings revealed that, students’ performance scores were higher in OSCE while comparing to TPE within and between the groups (P<0.001). Hence it is recommended that, OSCE can be effectively used as a part of formative and summative evaluation in Psychiatric Nursing.

Keywords

Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE), Traditional Practical Examination (TPE), Performance, Psychiatric Nursing, Nursing Students.
Subscription Login to verify subscription
User
Notifications
Font Size


  • Billings D M, Halstead J A. Teaching in Nursing. A guide for Faculty. Third edition, 2009: Elsevier Saunders. St Louis.

  • Khosravi S, Pazargadi M, Ashktorab T. Nursing Students’ viewpoints on challenges of student assessment in clinical Settings: A Qualitative Study.Iran J Educ Med2010; 11:736–48.

  • Hanleya E, Higginsb A. Assessment of practice in intensive care: Students’ perceptions of a clinical competence assessment tool.Intensive Crit Care Nurs2005; 21:276–83.[PubMed].

  • Wallace B. Practical issues of student assessment.Nurs Stand2003; 17:33–36.[PubMed].

  • Gerrow JD, Murphy HJ, Boyd MA, Scott DA. Concurrent validity of written and OSCE components of the Canadian dental certification examinations. Journal of Dental Education 2003; 67(8):896–901.

  • Marwaha S. Using Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCEs), Psychiatry and the clinical assessment of skills and competencies (CASC): Same Evidence, Different Judgment. BMC Psychiatry 2011; 11(85): 1-6.

  • Mavis B, Henry R. Between a rock and a hard place: Finding a place for the OSCE in medical education. Med. Educ 2002; 36 (5): 408-9.

  • Sleem W F, El-Shaer,Elatroush HG. Does Implementing for an Objective Structure Clinical Examination make a difference? Medical Jl Cairo University 2012; 80 (2): 239-47.

  • Harden RM, Gleeson FA. Assessment of clinical competencies using an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) In: ASME Medical Education Booklet No. 8. Dundee 1979, ASME.

  • Ananthakrishnan N. Objective structured clinical/practical examination (OSCE/OSPE). J Postgrad Med 1993; 39 (2):82-84.

  • Hasan S, Malik S, Hamad A, Khan H, Bilal M. Conventional/Traditional Practical examination (CEP/TDPE) versus Objective Structured Practical Evaluation (OSPE)/Semi Objective Structured Practical Evaluation (SOSPE). Pak Journal of Physiology 2009; 5(1): 58-64.

  • Roberts J, Norman G. Reliability and learning from the objective structured clinical examination. Medical Education 1990; 24: 219– 23.

  • Verma M, Singh T. Experiences with objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) as a tool for formative evaluation in Paediatrics. Indian Pediatr1993; 30:699-702.

  • Andrianopoulos N. Measuring the success of an objective structured clinical examination for dietetic students. J Hum Nutr Diet 2010; 23:212-16.

  • Schoonheim-Klein ME, Habets LL, Aartman IH, et al. Implementing an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) in dental education: effects on students’ learning strategies. Eur J Dent Educ 2006; 10: 226-35.

  • Jay A. Students’ perceptions of the OSCE: a valid assessment tool? British Journal of Midwifery 2007; 15(1): 32-37.

  • Sturpe DA. Objective Structured Clinical Examination in Doctor of Pharmacy programs in the United States. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2010; 74(8): Article 148. PubmedAbstract :PMID:21179259.

  • Zayyan M. Objective Structured Clinical Examination: The Assessment of choice. Oman Medical Journal 2011; 26 ( 4): 21922.

  • Loschen EL. The OSCE revisited: Use of performance-based evaluation in psychiatric education. Acad Psychiatry 2002;26:202204.

  • Mirfeizi M, Tourzani ZM,Babaheydari TB, Mirfeizi SZ,Jafarabadi MA,Mirheidar M,Khorsand G, GoodarziM. A Comparative Study on Evaluating of Knowledge and clinical Practices of Midwifery Students in the Courses of Physiopathology, Infectious and Internal Diseases and Surgery based on Objective Structured Clinical Examination and Traditional Assessment Methods. The Future of Medical Education Journal 2014; 2 (4): 3-8.

  • Nigam R, Mahawar P. Critical analysis of performance of MBBS students using OSPE and TDPE- a comparative study. National Journal of Community Medicine 2011; 2 (3): 322-24.

  • Zahid MJ, Al-Zayed A, Ohaeri J, Varghese R.O Introducing the Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) in the Undergraduate Psychiatric Curriculum: Evaluation After One Year. Academic Psychiatry 2011; 35:365–69.

  • Rahman N,Ferdousi S,Hoq N,Amin R,Kabir J. Evaluation of objective structured practical examination and traditional practical examination. Mymensingh Med J.2007 Jan; 16(1): 7-11. (Pubmed Abstract PMID: 17344771).

  • Jaywant SS, Pai AV. Evaluation and comparison of objective structured clinical examination an conventional clinical examination. The Indian Journal of Occupational Therapy 2009; Vol. XLI (1): 15-18.

  • Kundu D, Das HN, Sen G, Osta M, Mandal T, Gautam DJ. Objective structured practical examination in biochemistry: An experience in Medical College, Kolkata. Nat Sci Biol Med. 2013; 4(1): 103-7.

  • Ravichandran D, Shankar R, Malhotra V. A Comparative Study of Objective Structured Practical Examination with Conventional Practical Examination. International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012; 4 ( 7): 108-12.


Abstract Views: 304

PDF Views: 0




  • Performance of Nursing Students in Psychiatric Nursing using Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) Versus Traditional Practical Examination (TPE)- A Comparative Approach

Abstract Views: 304  |  PDF Views: 0

Authors

K. Vijayalakshmi
Apollo College of Nursing, Chennai, India
S. Revathi
Faculty of Nursing, Sri Ramachandra University, Chennai, India

Abstract


Determination of the quality of evaluation is an ongoing challenge to all educators. Selection of appropriate evaluation methods can enhance learning ability among nursing students and their performance in clinical tasks. The OSCE is a method of clinical evaluation which is highly comprehensive, systematic and objective and provides a uniform basis for evaluation of students. The present study was carried out to compare the nursing students’ performance between Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) and Traditional Practical Examination (TPE) in psychiatric nursing at Apollo College of Nursing, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, South India. Approval of the study was obtained from the Institutional review board, and Principal of Apollo College Nursing. Permission was obtained from the concerned authorities of the Psychiatric Hospital. Setting was selected through purposive sampling technique. The research design used for the study was randomized cross over research design with two groups. The study was conducted among 84 (42 students in each group) III year B.Sc. Nursing students, were selected using the consecutive sampling technique. The study subjects were randomly allocated to two groups (Group I and Group II) and then sequentially received two phases of intervention of OSCE and TPE or vice versa. Seventeen stations (including one rest station) OSCE and TPE were conducted in the private psychiatric hospital (100 marks each) with one-month washout period between these Examinations. Tools used in the study include baseline characteristics of the students, OSCE and TPE evaluation formats which were developed by the researcher. The collected data were organized, tabulated and statistically analyzed using appropriate descriptive and inferential statistics by SPSS software statistical computer package version 16. Study findings revealed that, students’ performance scores were higher in OSCE while comparing to TPE within and between the groups (P<0.001). Hence it is recommended that, OSCE can be effectively used as a part of formative and summative evaluation in Psychiatric Nursing.

Keywords


Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE), Traditional Practical Examination (TPE), Performance, Psychiatric Nursing, Nursing Students.

References