Research Cell: An International Journal of Engineering Sciences

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Saturation of Learning Curves in Defence Acquisition Projects


Affiliations
1 Development Canada Centre for Operational Research and Analysis Ottawa, Canada
 

Recent empirical evidence has shown that learning is a central cost risk factor in defence acquisition projects. The military learning-by-doing literature implicitly assumes that the marginal cost (or time) required to produce the nth unit (e.g., aircraft, ship) will asymptotically approach zero as n increases. It's assumed, in this paper, that the unit cost reaches a steady state where it remains constant over time. A new method that combines statistical analysis and stochastic simulation is suggested to estimate the distribution of the steady-state value. A case study on the acquisition of new warships is used to illustrate the approach. This model is general and can be applied to various defence acquisition projects.

Keywords

Learning Curves, Plateau Model, Cost Risk Profile, Simulation.
User
Notifications
Font Size

  • Ghanmi, A., Rempel, M., Abderrahmane Sokri, A., Solomon, B., and Ghergari, V. (2014). Cost Risk Framework. DRDC Scientific Report, DRDC-RDDC-2014-R167, Ottawa, Canada.

  • Sokri, A. and Ghanmi, A. (2017). Cost risk analysis and learning curve in the military shipbuilding sector. International Journal of Data Analysis Techniques and Strategies (In press).

  • Thompson, P. (2001). How much did the Liberty shipbuilders learn? New evidence for an old case study. Journal of Political Economy, 109(1) 103–137.

  • Arena, M.V., Younossi, O., Brancato, K., Blickstein, I., and Grammich, C.A. (2008). Why Has the Cost of Fixed-Wing Aircraft Risen? A Macroscopic Examination of the Trends in U.S. Military Aircraft Costs over the Past Several Decades, RAND Corporation Report MG-696NAVY/AF, CA, USA.

  • Kaluzny, B. (2011). The Unit Recurring Flyaway Cost of a Canadian Joint Strike Fighter. DRDC CORA TM 2011–200, Ottawa, Canada.

  • Sokri, A. and Ghanmi, A. (2015). Cost Risk Analysis Methods for Defence Acquisition Projects. International Conference on Risk Analysis, Barcelona, Spain, May 26-29.

  • Badiru, A.B., 1995. Multivariate analysis of the effect of learning and forgetting on product quality. International Journal of Production Research 33, 777–794.

  • Anzanello, M.J. and Fogliatto, F.S. (2011). Learning curve models and applications: Literature review and research directions. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 41: 573-583.

  • Hewitt, D., Sprague, K., Yearout, R., Lisnerski, D., and Sparks, C. (1992). The effects of unequal relearning rates on estimating forgetting parameters associated with performance curves. Int. J. Ind. Ergon., 10: 217–224.

  • Jaber, M.Y., 2006. Learning and forgetting models and their applications. In: Badiru, A.B. (Ed.), Handbook of Industrial & Systems Engineering. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp. 30.1e30.24.30.3.1

  • DeJong, J.R., 1957. The effects of increased skills on cycle time and its consequences for time standards. Ergonomics 1, 51–60.

  • Globerson, S. and Crossman, E.R.F.W. (1976). Minimization of worker induction and training cost through job enrichment. International Journal of Production Research, 14 (3).

  • Dar-El, E.M., 2000. Human Learning: from Learning Curves to Learning Organizations. Kluver Academic Publishers, Massachusetts.

  • Moore, J. R. (2015). A Comparative Study of Learning Curve Models In Defense Airframe Cost Estimating. Master’s Thesis, Air Force Institute of Technology, Graduate School of Engineering and Management, USA.

  • Younossi, O., Arena, M.V., Brancato, K., Graser, J.C., Goldsmith, B.W., Lorell, M.A., Timson, F., and Sollinger, J.M. (2007). F-22A Multiyear Procurement Program: An Assessment of Cost Savings, RAND Corporation Report MG-664-OSD, CA, USA.

  • Matthew S. Goldberg, M.S. and Touw, A. (2003). Statistical Methods for Learning Curves and Cost Analysis. The CNA Corporation, Virginia, USA.

  • Sokri, A. (2015). Arctic/Offshore Patrol Ship (AOPS). DRDC-RDDC2015-L224, July 2015.

  • Wright, T. P. (1936). Factors Affecting the Cost of Airplanes. Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences (Institute of the Aeronautical Sciences), 3(4): 122-128.

  • Yelle, L.E. (1979). The learning curve: historical review and comprehensive survey. Decision Science, 10(2): 302–328.

  • Li, G. and Rajagopalan, S. (1998). A learning curve model with knowledge depreciation. European Journal of Operational Research, 105: 143-154.

  • Stewart, R.D. and Wyskida, R.M. (1995). Cost Estimator’s Reference Manual. New York, NY: Wiley.

  • Sokri, A. and Solomon, B. (2013). Cost Risk Analysis and Contingency for the NGFC DRDC CORA Technical Memorandum TM 2013-224.


Abstract Views: 220

PDF Views: 2




  • Saturation of Learning Curves in Defence Acquisition Projects

Abstract Views: 220  |  PDF Views: 2

Authors

Abderrahmane Sokri
Development Canada Centre for Operational Research and Analysis Ottawa, Canada

Abstract


Recent empirical evidence has shown that learning is a central cost risk factor in defence acquisition projects. The military learning-by-doing literature implicitly assumes that the marginal cost (or time) required to produce the nth unit (e.g., aircraft, ship) will asymptotically approach zero as n increases. It's assumed, in this paper, that the unit cost reaches a steady state where it remains constant over time. A new method that combines statistical analysis and stochastic simulation is suggested to estimate the distribution of the steady-state value. A case study on the acquisition of new warships is used to illustrate the approach. This model is general and can be applied to various defence acquisition projects.

Keywords


Learning Curves, Plateau Model, Cost Risk Profile, Simulation.

References