Indian Journal of Science and Technology

Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Factors Influencing Human Errors during Work Permit Issuance by the Electric Power Transmission Network Operators


Affiliations
1 Occupational Health Eng Dept, International Branch, Shahid Beheshti Medical University, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
2 Occupational Health Eng Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Beheshti Medical University, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
3 Epidemiology Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Beheshti Medical University,Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
4 Occupational Health Eng Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoogi Medical University, Yazd, Iran, Islamic Republic of
5 Industrial Engineering Dept, School of Industrial Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
 

Prediction, identification, and control of errors effect on human performance and improve human actions. Human reliability has an important role in increasing the reliability of electricity production, transmission, and distribution networks and its direct/indirect damages. Right implementation of an effective work permit issuance system can meet safety of employees working in the control centre and other facilities and also can increase reliability of being used facilities. In the present research, effective factors for human errors in the process of work permit issuance by operators of control rooms working in the electricity transmission stations were studied. Substation operators' tasks, as the main human errors sources in the process of work permit issuance, were analyzed using hierarchical task analysis (HTA). Errors related to tasks were then predicted using systematic human error reduction and prediction (SHERPA) technique. The process of work permit issuance, as one of the main operators' tasks in which errors can be traced, was selected to analyze the impacts of some variables such as age, work experience, education level, hours of training, and number of maneuvers (number of permits issued by each operator). In the end, relationship between above variables and recorded errors was determined through Spearman's correlation coefficient. The results reveal that the action error and the error of maneuvering task have the most frequency respectively among the 107 predicted errors in six main tasks and 61 subtasks. The results also indicate a significant correlation (confidence level=95%) between the number of errors in the work permit issuance process and the Number of maneuvers (number of issued permits) (correlation coefficient=0.31&P=0), Training period (correlation coefficient=0.195&P=0.014), the work experience (correlation coefficient=0.191&P=0.016) and the age (correlation coefficient=0.164&p=0.014). There is also no significant correlation between the education level and the number of operator's errors in the work permit issuance process (correlation coefficient=-0.064&P=0.413). A reduction in human errors can be expected through the application of the identified factors effecting on operators' errors in power production and distribution networks.

Keywords

Operator, Work Permit, Human Error, HTA, SHERPA
User

  • Annett J (2003) Hierarchical task analysis. Handbook of cognitive task design. pp:17–35.

  • Annett J, Duncan KD, Stammers RB and Gray MJ (1971) Task Analysis (Department of Employment Training Information Paper No. 6). London, UK: Her Majesty's Stationary Office (HMSO).

  • Barry S (2002) Investigating human error: incidents, accidents, and complex systems. Ash gate Publ. Co.

  • Embrey D (1986) SHERPA: A systematic human error reduction and prediction approach. International Meeting on Advances in Nuclear Power Systems, Knoxville, Tennessee.

  • Ghasemi M (2009) Ergonomics Study (Identification, Prediction & Control) of Human Errors in a Control Room of Petrochemical Plants using SHERPA. A dissertation thesis for the fulfillment of the M.Sc. degree in Occupational Health Engineering, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, 2009, Tehran, Iran (Persian).

  • Haji Hoseini A (2010) Human error engineering. Part 1, Fanavaran publishing Co. (Persian)

  • Haji Hoseini A (2011) Prediction and reduction of human errors in operators of control rooms in Yazd Regional Electric Power Supply & Distribution Co, using SHERPA. A dissertation thesis for the fulfillment of the M.Sc. degree in Occupational Health Engineering, University of Shahid Beheshti (MC), International Branch, Tehran, Iran (Persian).

  • Harrison D and Stanton NA (2006) Applying hierarchical task analysis to Medication administration errors. Appl. Ergonomics. 37, 669–679.

  • Jahangiri M (2005) Human error Identification and Analysis in Isomax Unit of Tehran Oil Refinery, using PHEA. A dissertation thesis for the fulfillment of the M.Sc. degree in Occupational Health Engineering, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, 2005, Tehran, Iran, (Persian).

  • Mahdavi S (2007) Human error identification & assessment in the control room of sulfur regain unit of Tehran Oil Refinery using HEIST. A thesis submitted for the fulfillment of the M.Sc. degree in Occupational Health Engineering, Tarbiat Moddaress University, Tehran, Iran, 2007(Persian)

  • Mostia B (2002) Human error in instrumentation systems –part 1, Control Global, December 13. available at http://www.controlglobal.com/articles/2006/140.html.

  • Patrick J, Spurgeon P and Shepherd A (2006) A guide to task analysis: Applications of hierarchical methods. Occupational Publ.

  • Peterson JD (1996) Human error reduction & safety management. Van Nostrand Reinhold, 3rd ed.

  • Shah Gholi-Nejad N (2012) Structure of human errors in tasks of operators working in the control room of an oil refinery unit. Indian J. Sci.Technol.5 (2), 2065- 2070.

  • Stanton NA (2006) Hierarchical task analysis: Developments, applications, and extensions. Appl. Ergonomics. 37(1), 55–79.

  • Stanton N and Young MS (1999) A guide to methodology in ergonomics: designing for human use. CRC.

  • Stanton N and Salmon P (2004) Human factors design & evaluation methods review. Defense Technology Center, February.

  • Zarea R (1996) Human errors of operators in cement furnace using HRMS. A dissertation thesis for the fulfillment of the M.Sc. degree in Occupational Health Engineering, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, (Persian).


Abstract Views: 534

PDF Views: 120




  • Factors Influencing Human Errors during Work Permit Issuance by the Electric Power Transmission Network Operators

Abstract Views: 534  |  PDF Views: 120

Authors

A. R. Haji Hosseini
Occupational Health Eng Dept, International Branch, Shahid Beheshti Medical University, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
M. J. Jafari
Occupational Health Eng Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Beheshti Medical University, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
Y. Mehrabi
Epidemiology Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Beheshti Medical University,Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of
G. H. Halwani
Occupational Health Eng Dept, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoogi Medical University, Yazd, Iran, Islamic Republic of
A. Ahmadi
Industrial Engineering Dept, School of Industrial Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran, Islamic Republic of

Abstract


Prediction, identification, and control of errors effect on human performance and improve human actions. Human reliability has an important role in increasing the reliability of electricity production, transmission, and distribution networks and its direct/indirect damages. Right implementation of an effective work permit issuance system can meet safety of employees working in the control centre and other facilities and also can increase reliability of being used facilities. In the present research, effective factors for human errors in the process of work permit issuance by operators of control rooms working in the electricity transmission stations were studied. Substation operators' tasks, as the main human errors sources in the process of work permit issuance, were analyzed using hierarchical task analysis (HTA). Errors related to tasks were then predicted using systematic human error reduction and prediction (SHERPA) technique. The process of work permit issuance, as one of the main operators' tasks in which errors can be traced, was selected to analyze the impacts of some variables such as age, work experience, education level, hours of training, and number of maneuvers (number of permits issued by each operator). In the end, relationship between above variables and recorded errors was determined through Spearman's correlation coefficient. The results reveal that the action error and the error of maneuvering task have the most frequency respectively among the 107 predicted errors in six main tasks and 61 subtasks. The results also indicate a significant correlation (confidence level=95%) between the number of errors in the work permit issuance process and the Number of maneuvers (number of issued permits) (correlation coefficient=0.31&P=0), Training period (correlation coefficient=0.195&P=0.014), the work experience (correlation coefficient=0.191&P=0.016) and the age (correlation coefficient=0.164&p=0.014). There is also no significant correlation between the education level and the number of operator's errors in the work permit issuance process (correlation coefficient=-0.064&P=0.413). A reduction in human errors can be expected through the application of the identified factors effecting on operators' errors in power production and distribution networks.

Keywords


Operator, Work Permit, Human Error, HTA, SHERPA

References





DOI: https://doi.org/10.17485/ijst%2F2012%2Fv5i8%2F30534